Hey guys.
I had been corresponding with a representative from Nars for about a month now. Of course, to get the details on their cruelty-free status. As I researched, I managed to learn bareMineral's cruelty-free status as well, along with a
collection of other companies. Some I'm sure you probably never heard of and some maybe you have. I'm just listing Nars & baraMinerals because they are the most well known.
They will also be on
my cruelty-free list.
So get ready, this is going to be lengthy.
I know a lot of you are anxious to hear whether these very popular & lusted after companies are cruelty-free.
I hope to help clear the rumors you might have heard.
I began by emailing them. I won't share it, just to save you some time and to get to the point. (If you're really curious, it went something like: "I'm a [potential] costumer and I demand to be listened to!!"
I then received a series of email, so get ready to do a bit of reading.
Dear Camila,
Thank you for contacting NARS Cosmetics.
While NARS is not a member of PETA, Nars does not test on animals, nor do we have any other parties, including our suppliers, conduct animal testing on our behalf. Nars uses only the highest quality ingredients which have a proven safety record and are widely used in the cosmetics industry. If you are questioning a particular product ingredients, please specify the product and we will be able to better answer your question. If we can assist you further please don't hesitate to contact us.
Kind regards,
[I've omitted any names]
Customer DesiresNARS Cosmetics
I have a few problems with that email. For one, they say "nor do we have any other parties, including your suppliers, conduct animal testing.." To me that says, 'although we do not encourage third party animal testing, we do not exactly demand that third party companies DO NOT conduct animal testing'. Hopefully, you understand what I'm getting at.
They were not clear on the China issue. I had included that as a question in my original email. Therefore, I emailed them again.
"Thank you for contacting me so promptly.
Why doesn't Nars become affiliated with PETA? It would help people, like myself, that only purchase cruelty-free products. Also it would open a huge new market target. Also, does Nars sell to China? I'm sure you are aware of China's animal testing policy.
-Camila Alvarez
I always like asking them about becoming affiliated with a animal rights group.(i.e. PETA, LeapingBunny). I feel that it saves time for people who only purchase cruelty-free products.
Maybe a day or two later I received this email:
Dear Camila,
We are not aware of any plan to retail in China.
NARS is owned by Shiseido.
If we can assist you further please don't hesitate to contact us.
Kind regards,
[I've omitted any names]
Customer DesiresNARS Cosmetics
This is where my research became interesting. As you know, from the description of this blog. I do not support companies who are "cruelty-free" but are owned by companies that are NOT cruelty-free.
It does not make any sense to me. If you buy from those types of companies, your money is going toward who knows what. You might be funding the animal testing.
I then went on
Shiseido's website. Before this correspondence I had never heard of Shiseido. Apparently, they are a separate beauty company and the parents of Nars, bareMinerals, etc. They apparently own: Nars and bareMinerals, and a bunch of other companies. Click
here to see that list.
They own makeup companies, they also own skincare, haircare, body care companies.
After my eyes starting hurting from looking at all the companies they own. I went to see if they sell in China. And I'm sure you can guess, that
of course they sell in China. Here is their
Chinese website. That's evidence enough for me.
So, are Nars & bareMinerals (they are both owned by Shiseido) cruelty-free?
Of course not. I didn't even bother to check the section where, they mention all the work they have done to end animal testing, because frankly I'm tired of reading that crap over-and-over again.
I hope this post helped you in some form. I know I was not surprised to hear that Nars is not cruelty-free, I was however somewhat surprised to hear that bareMinerals is not. Either way, I don't own any of their products so I wont be missing them. I'm sorry if you are a huge Nars or bareMinerals fan, and this news is hard to swallow. Just remember that the life of an innocent bunny, cat, or dog is more precious than participating in a beauty trend. Also, bunnies, dogs, and cats are not going to be using these products, so it's not fair for them to sacrifice their lives, for something so insignificant in the grand scheme of things.
Don't get me wrong I'm a true, girls-girl but I know where to draw the line. Do you?